Don’t Do Congress’ Job – Commentary

The statements made when the USPS Board of Governors meets say more than the words they contain, and those made at the recent meeting were no exceptions.  In some cases, the formal remarks – carefully drafted by USPS publicists and honed by the agency’s lawyers – reflect an official position that outsiders might believe at odds with reality.

For example, in his “prepared remarks,” Postmaster General David Steiner offered that

“… our results for [Fiscal 2026] show a positive trajectory in virtually all of the areas where we have the ability to exercise control over our business. … With regard to service, we are now demonstrating consistent performance improvement month over month. … With regard to cost control, we are also becoming more efficient in key areas while improving service. … And, we did this despite volumes declining in the quarter.  So, despite volumes being negative, we are now meeting our revenue goals on a regular basis … the result of effective pricing strategies combined with strong promotions, strong incentives, and product development in our mail business. …”

Many observers might not agree that there is “a positive trajectory” in service, revenue growth, or cost control, but would agree that the Postal Service’s CEO can’t say anything that didn’t cast the agency’s performance in a favorable light.  Similarly, Steiner, as expected, used the opportunity to again warn of a looming financial crisis, press his legislative agenda, and imply dire consequences if Congress is uncooperative.

“… we believe that there are one of two paths that Congress can choose from.

“The first is the removal of uneconomical mandates that prevent us from functioning as the self-sufficient business that we are expected to be.  If we removed the mandates, we would overcome our controllable loss in six months.

“The second option is to fund these uneconomical mandates.  The USPS is the core of a nearly $2 trillion ecosystem, supporting almost 8 million jobs, and providing critical infrastructure that reaches every address in the country.  Any financial support to cover the shortfall would be an investment in one of the central pillars of the US economy. …

“Basically, given all of the restrictions placed on us, our big money-saving choices are limited to looking at rationalizing our retail and office footprint consistent with our financial obligations, and service standards for non-First-Class Mail.  We will need to make drastic changes in the number of Post Offices and Marketing Mail service levels.  And we will need to look at other areas to generate the cash we need to meet our obligations to our employees and the American public. …”

The Plan

An ongoing circumstance for the governors and senior USPS management – one they brought on themselves and continue to embrace – is the 10-Year Plan produced by former PMG Louis DeJoy.  Perhaps it was presented to the governors as the best or only option, or perhaps DeJoy persuaded (or browbeat) them to believe it was virtually certain to work; regardless, the governors approved it.  Now, evidence continues to show it’s not working, yet they won’t disavow it.

Allegedly, David Steiner was hired with the mandate to stick with The Plan, which he apparently has, even though any independent consideration of it – beyond the influence of DeJoy acolytes he retained – would provide little reason to do so.  No matter how official statements may try to paint a rosy picture, the Postal Service’s financial results and service performance scores are not what The Plan predicted.

Making cuts

If Steiner believes The Plan should be continued, presumably eventually delivering what it promised, it seems inconsistent to threaten drastic cuts in service if Congress doesn’t act to provide further relief The Plan never sought.  Simply put, if The Plan is working, why are additional legislative actions or the potential cuts needed?

Conversely, if The Plan is not working, why isn’t it abandoned – publicly?

To be clear, there shouldn’t be debate about the value of the items on his legislative agenda – like revising the USPS borrowing limit, smarter investment of USPS funds, allowing more businesslike management of workers’ comp, and recalculating the pension obligation for former Post Office Department employees (only the fourth item was in the 10-Year Plan), so they shouldn’t incite political passions.

Regardless, if the PMG believes Congress should act, why is he easing the pressure on it by planning to implement unpopular measures on his own?  Doing so would draw fire to him and the USPS from Congress and let the blame be laid at his doorstep.  Presumably, by assuming the authority to order distasteful measures he would be stating that, as the CEO of the Postal Service, he has the latitude to trim his agency’s public services to fit within its budget.  Congress will leave Steiner on his own to cut services and raise prices in the likely vain hope of someday balancing the books.

Conversely, it could be argued that the better strategy would be to force Congress’ hand.  The nation’s legislators are wont to do two things: nothing or panic.  In other words, so long as Steiner is willing to be the bad guy they’ll do nothing.  Congress will criticize whatever he does but won’t intercede.

However, if the PMG retained all the unprofitable post offices, spent to provide genuinely better service, continued six-day delivery (as DeJoy had Congress make a statutory mandate), and generally pursued the best public service version of the Postal Service, he very likely would precipitate a financial crisis.  In turn, suddenly realizing the ensuing public (i.e., voter) outcry should it let the USPS fail, Congress would reach the necessary level of panic to act.

At that point, Steiner’s legislative requests might be granted, but the real core issue needs to be resolved: exactly what is the Universal Service Obligation and how will it be funded?  Borrowing more or investing differently won’t answer that fundamental question that only Congress can – or should – answer.  It’s avoided it for decades while the POD and USPS finances and service were acceptable, but they aren’t any longer; it’s time for Congress to define and fund the USO.

Steiner likes to say that the USPS can do whatever it’s asked if someone will pay for it.  Accordingly, he should not try to meet USO requirements with the money he has, but create a situation where those who expect such service must reckon with paying for it.  The PMG should stop taking it upon himself to do Congress’ job.

Related posts