It’s neither uncommon nor surprising that something can be seen or interpreted two ways, especially if the viewers approach that which is observed from different perspectives. In this case, the “something” is the service performance of the Postal Service.
The USPS
For its part, the agency had in the past set demanding performance standards and usually achieved them, but that’s no longer true. Starting under the reign of former postmaster general Louis DeJoy, the USPS reinterpreted the term “efficiency” to justify lowering service standards, inventing measurement loopholes, and cutting transportation.
As a result, the Postal Service may still have service targets (that are lower than in the past) but still struggles to reach them. Despite this underachievement, the USPS publicists keep bragging about “performance excellence” and its allegedly ongoing improvement to service.
The customer
Meanwhile, ratepaying customers – generally out of the loop regarding published service information – learn of the agency’s service deficiencies by real experience.
Earlier in October, as the election approached and concerns about mailed ballots were raised, staff from Portland (OR) station KGW posted “100 letters from dozens of locations across Oregon on the same day.” The primary observed situation was about postmarks:
“Only 14 of the 100 letters received a same-day postmark. Another 85 were postmarked one or two days later. One envelope arrived without a postmark at all.”
Given the widespread use of mail-in ballots in the state, the point of the story was not just the time from mailing to delivery but the insufficiency of a postmark to prove timely mailing of the ballot.
When asked, a USPS representative stated the obvious:
“This means the date on the postmark does not necessarily match the date that the mailpiece was collected by a letter carrier, dropped off at a retail location, or placed in a collection box.”
Another test of service was conducted in mid-October by Spectrum News, as it reported October 21:
“With roughly 1 in 5 Americans expected to cast ballots by mail in the November election, Spectrum News decided to put the Postal Service to the test, mailing letters across the country and tracking them to determine whether the USPS is meeting its basic service standards, listed on its website, of delivering local, first-class mail within two business days.
“Spectrum News journalists in Washington, D.C., and eight states – New York, Ohio, Kentucky, Missouri, Alabama, Michigan, Wisconsin and California – took part in the investigation.
“Five Spectrum News journalists spread across each region mailed one envelope to each other every day for five business days. Each envelope was supposed to be mailed by 10am, dropped into the collection slot inside the local post office. Of the 225 envelopes mailed, 213 met those requirements. Eighty-nine of those 213 envelopes took longer than two business days to reach their destination, a failure rate of 41.7%. New York had the best on-time performance, with a failure rate of just 4.5%. Alabama had the worst record in our test; 88% of the mail there was delivered late.
“Several letters were delivered long past the two-day standard. Three letters in Alabama took seven business days to reach their destinations. One envelope in Washington was delivered after nine business days. Michigan and Ohio each had one envelope take longer than seven business days.”
Observations
The Postal Service likely doesn’t consider those tests as valid indicators of service but, for the customer – whether a news organization or simply a voter – the Postal Service’s interpretations and excuses are just as invalid. The customer’s experience is what defines the service the USPS provided.
The current postmaster general – who has retained the DeJoy staff leading the drive for “efficiency” – likes to argue that the Postal Service can’t afford to collect mail from all post office twice a day, or to use air carriers to move mail long distances, so service reductions are essential because the USPS is “out of cash.” Service can be improved, he adds, if someone is willing to pay for it. The disconnect for most observers is that, ten years ago, the agency had more mail to move, through its existing network and facilities, and was able to meet tougher service targets. Now, however, will less mail, updated facilities, a revised network, and the same size workforce, it can’t hit even the lower targets it set for itself. So much for “excellence.”
